44 CFR 152.5 - Review process and evaluation criteria.

§ 152.5 Review process and evaluation criteria.

(a) Every application will be evaluated based on the answers to the activity-specific questions during our initial screening. The applications that are determined to best address the Assistance to Firefighters Grant Program's established priorities during this initial screening will be in the “competitive range” and subject to a second level of review. We will use the narratives/supplemental information provided by the applicants in their grant applications to evaluate, on a competitive basis, the merits and benefits of each request for funding. In selecting applications for award, we will evaluate each application for assistance independently based on established eligibility criteria and the program priorities. Eligible applicants that best address the priorities will advance to a second level of review. The second level of review involves an assessment of the financial needs of the applicant, and an analysis of the benefits that would result from the grant award.

(b) In order to be successful at this second level of the evaluation, an applicant must complete the narrative section of the application package. The narrative should include a detailed description of the planned program, uses for the grant funds including details of each budget line item. For example, if personnel costs are included in the budget, please provide a break down of what those costs are for. The narrative should explain why the grant funds are needed and why the department has not been able to obtain funding for the planned activities on its own. A discussion of financial need should include a discussion of any Federal funding received for similar activities. Finally, the applicant's narrative should detail the benefits the department or community will realize as a result of the grant award.

(c) This second level of review will be conducted using a panel of technical evaluation panelists. These panelists are largely made up of non-Federal experts with a fire service background. The panelists will assess the application's merits with respect to the clarity and detail provided in the narrative about the project, the applicant's financial need, and the project's purported benefit to be derived from the cost. Technical evaluation panelists will independently score each application before them and then discuss the merits/shortcomings of the application in an effort to reconcile any major discrepancies. A consensus on the score is not required. The highest scoring applications resulting from this second level of review will then be considered for award. We seek to maximize the benefits derived from the funding by crediting applicants with the greatest financial need and whose proposed activities provide the greatest benefit versus the cost.

(d) In addition to the project narrative, the applicant must provide an itemized budget detailing the use of the grant funds. If an applicant is seeking funds in more than one eligible activity within a program, separate budgets will have to be generated for each activity and then an overall or summary budget will have to be generated. For those applicants applying on line, the summary budget will be automatically generated by the e-grants system.

(e) Specific rating criteria for each of the eligible programs will be published in a Notice of Funding Availability that we will publish pursuant to the program's annual appropriation.

This is a list of United States Code sections, Statutes at Large, Public Laws, and Presidential Documents, which provide rulemaking authority for this CFR Part.

This list is taken from the Parallel Table of Authorities and Rules provided by GPO [Government Printing Office].

It is not guaranteed to be accurate or up-to-date, though we do refresh the database weekly. More limitations on accuracy are described at the GPO site.

United States Code
U.S. Code: Title 15 - COMMERCE AND TRADE

§ 2201 - Congressional findings

§ 2202 - Declaration of purpose

§ 2203 - Definitions

§ 2204 - United States Fire Administration

§ 2205 - Public education

§ 2206 - National Academy for Fire Prevention and Control

§ 2207 - Fire technology

§ 2208 - National Fire Data Center

§ 2209 - Master plans

§ 2210 - Reimbursement for costs of firefighting on Federal property

§ 2211 - Review of fire prevention codes

§ 2212 - Fire safety effectiveness statements

§ 2213 - Annual conference

§ 2214 - Public safety awards

§ 2215 - Reports to Congress and President

§ 2216 - Authorization of appropriations

§ 2217 - Public access to information

§ 2218 - Administrative provisions

§ 2219 - Assistance to Consumer Product Safety Commission

§ 2220 - Arson prevention, detection, and control

§ 2221 - Arson prevention grants

§ 2222 - Repealed. Pub. L. 106–503, title I, § 110(a)(1)(B), Nov. 13, 2000, 114 Stat. 2302

§ 2223a - Review

§ 2223b - Working group

§ 2223c - Report and recommendations

§ 2223d - Annual revision of recommendations

§ 2223e - “Emergency response personnel” defined

§ 2224 - Listings of places of public accommodation

§ 2225 - Fire prevention and control guidelines for places of public accommodation

§ 2225a - Prohibiting Federal funding of conferences held at non-certified places of public accommodation

§ 2226 - Dissemination of fire prevention and control information

§ 2227 - Fire safety systems in federally assisted buildings

§ 2228 - CPR training

§ 2229 - Firefighter assistance

§ 2229a - Staffing for adequate fire and emergency response

§ 2230 - Surplus and excess Federal equipment

§ 2231 - Cooperative agreements with Federal facilities

§ 2232 - Burn research

§ 2233 - Removal of civil liability barriers that discourage the donation of fire equipment to volunteer fire companies

§ 2234 - Encouraging adoption of standards for firefighter health and safety

The section you are viewing is cited by the following CFR sections.