Ancich v. Ancich, Ariz. App. (2009)

In Ancich v. Ancich, the Arizona Court of Appeals affirmed the issuance of an order of protection in favor of the respondent against her former husband. The parties, who shared joint custody of their minor son, had divorced in 2003. In 2008, the respondent sought an order of protection alleging that the petitioner had physically abused their son and threatened her. At the hearing, the respondent testified that the petitioner had attempted to pull over her vehicle, arrived at her home in an agitated state, and stated, “I’d love to beat the shit out of you,” in front of their child. The trial court found reasonable cause to believe that domestic violence had occurred or might occur between the parties and concluded that the petitioner had committed disorderly conduct or attempted to intimidate or threaten the respondent. Although the court removed the child from the order due to insufficient evidence and lifted firearm restrictions after clarification, it maintained the order protecting the respondent. On appeal, the petitioner argued that the order was based on grounds not specifically alleged in the petition and that it infringed on his custodial and firearm rights. The Court of Appeals rejected these arguments, holding that the petitioner had waived certain objections by failing to raise them at trial, that the trial court properly resolved credibility disputes, and that the remaining restrictions did not unduly burden his parental rights. The court affirmed the order of protection. This case summary is not legal precedent and is provided for educational purposes only.

Topics