(b) Groundwater Monitoring System.
(1) Except as provided under subsection
(e)(3) of this section, the owner or operator shall establish a groundwater
monitoring system for each regulated unit. This groundwater monitoring system
shall include:
(A) a sufficient number of
background monitoring points installed at appropriate locations and depths to
yield groundwater samples from the uppermost aquifer that represent the quality
of groundwater that has not been affected by a release from the regulated
unit;
(B) for a detection
monitoring program under section
66264.98:
1. a sufficient number of monitoring points
installed at appropriate locations and depths to yield groundwater samples from
the uppermost aquifer that represent the quality of groundwater passing the
point of compliance and to allow for the detection of a release from the
regulated unit;
2. a sufficient
number of monitoring points installed at additional locations and depths to
yield groundwater samples from the uppermost aquifer as necessary to provide
the best assurance of the earliest possible detection of a release from the
regulated unit; and
3. a sufficient
number of monitoring points and background monitoring points installed at
appropriate locations and depths to yield groundwater samples from other
aquifers, low-yielding saturated zones and from zones of perched water as
necessary to provide the best assurance of the earliest possible detection of a
release from the regulated unit;
(C) for an evaluation monitoring program
under section
66264.99:
1. a sufficient number of monitoring points
installed at appropriate locations and depths to yield groundwater samples from
the uppermost aquifer that represent the quality of groundwater passing the
point of compliance, and at other locations in the uppermost aquifer as
necessary, to provide the data needed to evaluate changes in water quality due
to the release from the regulated unit; and
2. a sufficient number of monitoring points
and background monitoring points installed at appropriate locations and depths
to yield groundwater samples from other aquifers, low-yielding saturated zones
and zones of perched water as necessary to provide the data needed to evaluate
changes in water quality due to the release from the regulated
unit;
(D) for a
corrective action program under section
66264.100 of this article:
1. a sufficient number of monitoring points
installed at appropriate locations and depths to yield groundwater samples from
the uppermost aquifer that represent the quality of groundwater passing the
point of compliance, and at other locations in the uppermost aquifer as
necessary, to provide the data needed to evaluate compliance with the water
quality protection standard and to evaluate the effectiveness of the corrective
action program; and
2. a sufficient
number of monitoring points and background monitoring points installed at
appropriate locations and depths to yield groundwater samples from other
aquifers, low-yielding saturated zones and zones of perched water as necessary
to provide the data needed to evaluate compliance with the water quality
protection standard and to evaluate the effectiveness of the corrective action
program.
(2)
The groundwater monitoring system may include background monitoring points that
are not hydraulically upgradient of the regulated unit if the owner or operator
demonstrates to the satisfaction of the Department that sampling at other
monitoring points will provide samples that are representative of the
background quality of groundwater or are more representative than those
provided by the upgradient monitoring points.
(3) A copy of each well report, as required
by Water Code section
13751, shall be
submitted to the Department within 60 days of the construction, alteration, or
destruction of the well.
(4) All
monitoring wells shall be cased and constructed in a manner that maintains the
integrity of the monitoring well bore hole and prevents the bore hole from
acting as a conduit for contaminant transport.
(5) The sampling interval of each monitoring
well shall be appropriately screened and fitted with an appropriate filter pack
to enable collection of representative groundwater samples.
(6) For each monitoring well the annular
space (i.e., the space between the bore hole and well casing) above and below
the sampling interval shall be appropriately sealed to prevent entry of
contaminants from the surface, entry of contaminants from the unsaturated zone,
cross contamination of saturated zones and contamination of samples.
(7) All monitoring wells shall be adequately
developed to enable collection of representative groundwater samples.
(8) All wells shall be adequately destroyed
(decommissioned) if the wells will no longer provide useful information.
Decommissioning may only proceed after approval by the Department or as
directed by the Department.
(d) Unsaturated
Zone Monitoring System.
(1) Except as
otherwise provided in subsections (d)(5) and (d)(7) of this section, the owner
or operator shall establish an unsaturated zone monitoring system for each
regulated unit.
(2) The unsaturated
zone monitoring system shall include:
(A) a
sufficient number of background monitoring points established at appropriate
locations and depths to yield soil-pore liquid samples or soil-pore liquid
measurements that represent the quality of soil-pore liquid that has not been
affected by a release from the regulated unit;
(B) for a detection monitoring program under
section
66264.98, a sufficient number of
monitoring points established at appropriate locations and depths to yield
soil-pore liquid samples or soil-pore liquid measurements that provide the best
assurance of the earliest possible detection of a release from the regulated
unit;
(C) for an evaluation
monitoring program under section
66264.99, a sufficient number of
monitoring points established at appropriate locations and depths to yield
soil-pore liquid samples or soil-pore liquid measurements as necessary to
provide the data needed to evaluate changes in water quality due to the release
from the regulated unit; and
(D)
for a corrective action program under section
66264.100, a sufficient number of
monitoring points established at appropriate locations and depths to yield
soil-pore liquid samples or soil-pore liquid measurements as necessary to
provide the data needed to evaluate compliance with the water quality
protection standard and to evaluate the effectiveness of the corrective action
program.
(3) Background
monitoring points shall be installed at a background plot having soil
characteristics similar to those of the soil underlying the regulated
unit.
(4) Liquid recovery types of
unsaturated zone monitoring (e.g., the use of lysimeters) are required unless
the owner or operator demonstrates to the satisfaction of the Department that
such methods of unsaturated zone monitoring cannot provide useful information
regarding a release from the regulated unit. The Department shall require
complementary or alternative (non-liquid recovery) types of unsaturated zone
monitoring as necessary to adequately monitor a release from the regulated
unit.
(5) Unsaturated zone
monitoring is required at all new regulated units unless the owner or operator
demonstrates to the satisfaction of the Department that no method for
unsaturated zone monitoring can provide any indication of a release from that
regulated unit.
(6) The owner or
operator of a land treatment unit shall comply with the unsaturated zone
monitoring and response requirements for that unit in article 13 of this
chapter, in addition to the unsaturated zone monitoring requirements of this
article.
(7) The owner or operator
may modify or exclude certain chapter 14, article 6 requirements pertaining to
unsaturated zone monitoring if it is impracticable (e.g., insufficient liquid
volume for analyses) or technically inappropriate to conduct unsaturated zone
monitoring at the regulated unit. The owner or operator shall make an
appropriate demonstration for alternative unsaturated zone monitoring
requirements. The owner or operator is not relieved of any unsaturated zone
monitoring requirements until the Department evaluates the proposal and issues
or modifies the permit.
(e) General Monitoring Requirements.
(1) All monitoring systems shall be designed
and certified by a registered geologist or a registered civil
engineer.
(2) All monitoring wells
and all other borings drilled to satisfy the requirements of this article shall
be logged during drilling under the direct supervision of a registered
geologist. These logs shall be submitted to the Department upon completion of
drilling.
(A) Soil shall be described in the
geologic log according to the Unified Soil Classification System as presented
in Geotechnical Branch Training Manuals nos. 4, 5 and 6, published by the
United States Bureau of Reclamation, January 1986 incorporated by reference in
section
66260.11 of this
division.
(B) Rock shall be
described in the geologic log in a manner appropriate for the purpose of the
investigation.
(C) Where possible,
the depth and thickness of saturated zones shall be recorded in the geologic
log.
(3) If a facility
contains contiguous regulated units, separate groundwater monitoring systems
are not required for each such unit if the owner or operator demonstrates to
the satisfaction of the Department that the water quality monitoring program
for each unit will enable the earliest possible detection and measurement of a
release from that unit.
(4) The
water quality monitoring program shall include and implement consistent
sampling and analytical procedures that are designed to ensure that monitoring
results provide a reliable indication of water quality at all monitoring points
and background monitoring points. At a minimum the program shall include a
detailed description of the procedures and techniques for:
(A) sample collection (e.g., purging
techniques, sampling equipment and decontamination of sampling
equipment);
(B) sample preservation
and shipment;
(C) analytical
procedures; and
(D) chain of
custody control.
(5) The
water quality monitoring program shall include appropriate sampling and
analytical methods for groundwater, surface water and the unsaturated zone that
accurately measure the concentration of each constituent of concern and the
concentration or value of each monitoring parameter.
(6) For each regulated unit, the owner or
operator shall collect all data necessary for selecting the appropriate
statistical method pursuant to subsections (e)(7), (e)(8) and (e)(9) of this
section and for establishing the background values pursuant to subsection
(e)(11) of this section. At a minimum, this data shall include analytical data
obtained during quarterly sampling of all background monitoring points for a
period of one year, including the times of expected highest and lowest annual
elevations of the groundwater surface. The Department may approve sampling at
times other than the expected highest and lowest annual elevations, if
appropriate, however quarterly sampling is still required for a period of at
least one year. For a new regulated unit, this data shall be collected before
wastes are discharged at the unit and background soil pore liquid data shall be
collected from beneath the unit before the unit is constructed.
(7) Based on data collected pursuant to
subsection (e)(6) of this section, the owner or operator shall propose one of
the statistical methods specified in subsection (e)(8) of this section for each
constituent of concern and for each monitoring parameter. These methods, upon
approval by the Department, shall be specified in the facility permit and shall
be used in evaluating water quality monitoring data. The specifications for
each statistical method shall include a detailed description of the criteria to
be used for determining statistically significant evidence of any release from
the regulated unit and for determining compliance with the water quality
protection standard. Each statistical test specified for a particular
constituent of concern or monitoring parameter shall be conducted separately
for that constituent of concern or monitoring parameter at each monitoring
point. Where practical quantitation limits are used in any of the following
statistical methods to comply with subsection (e)(9)(E) of this section, the
practical quantitation limit shall be proposed by the owner or operator for
approval by the Department. The owner or operator shall demonstrate that use of
the proposed statistical methods will be protective of human health and the
environment and will comply with the performance standards outlined in
subsection (e)(9) of this section.
(8) The owner or operator shall propose one
of the following statistical methods:
(A) a
parametric analysis of variance (ANOVA) followed in all instances by a multiple
comparisons procedure to identify statistically significant evidence of a
release from the regulated unit. The method shall include estimation and
testing of the contrasts between each monitoring point's mean and the
background mean value for each constituent of concern or monitoring
parameter;
(B) an ANOVA based on
ranks followed in all instances by a multiple comparisons procedure to identify
statistically significant evidence of a release from the regulated unit. The
method shall include estimation and testing of the contrasts between each
monitoring point's median and the background median values for each constituent
of concern or monitoring parameter;
(C) a tolerance or prediction interval
procedure in which an interval for each constituent of concern or monitoring
parameter is established from the distribution of the background data, and the
value for each constituent of concern or monitoring parameter at each
monitoring point is compared to the upper tolerance or prediction
limit;
(D) a control chart approach
that gives control limits for each constituent of concern or monitoring
parameter; or
(E) another
statistical test method submitted by the owner or operator for approval by the
Department including, but not limited to, any statistical method which includes
a procedure to verify that there is statistically significant evidence of a
release from the regulated unit. If the statistical test method includes a
verification procedure, this procedure shall consist of either a single
composite retest (i.e., a statistical analysis of the original data combined
with newly-acquired data from the monitoring point at which evidence of a
release has been indicated) or shall consist of at least two discrete retests
(i.e., statistical analyses which analyze only newly-acquired data from the
monitoring point at which evidence of a release has been indicated). The
verification procedure shall comply with the following requirements in addition
to the statistical performance standards under subsection (e)(9) of this
section.
1. If the verification procedure
consists of discrete retests, rejection of the null hypothesis for any one of
the retests shall be considered confirmation of significant evidence of a
release.
2. The number of
additional samples collected and analyzed for use in the verification procedure
shall be appropriate for the form of statistical test specified in the facility
permit for that constituent of concern or monitoring parameter pursuant to
subsection (e)(7) of this section. This number shall be greater than or equal
to the number of samples specified in the facility permit for that constituent
of concern or monitoring parameter pursuant to subsection (e)(12)(A) of this
section.
3. If resampling at the
interval identified for use in the initial statistical test pursuant to
subsection (e)(12)(B) of this section would cause the entire resampling effort
to take longer than 30 days, the sampling interval for use in the verification
procedure shall be reduced to ensure that all samples are collected and
submitted for laboratory analysis within 30 calendar days from the time that
the owner or operator determines statistically significant evidence of a
release pursuant to subsection
66264.98(g) or
(i). Resampling may occur within a different
time frame provided the owner or operator receives written approval from the
Department.
4. For a verification
procedure consisting of a composite retest, the statistical verification
procedure shall be based on all data obtained from the initial sampling event
combined with all data obtained during the resampling event. For a verification
procedure containing discrete retests, each retest shall analyze data obtained
during its respective resampling event(s) and no data shall be shared between
retests.
5. For a verification
procedure consisting of a composite retest, the statistical test method used in
the verification procedure shall be the same as the method used in the initial
statistical comparison, except that the statistical test used in the
verification procedure shall be conducted at a Type I error level of no less
than 0.05 for both the experiment-wise analysis (if any) and the individual
monitoring point comparisons; therefore, if a control chart approach is used to
evaluate water quality monitoring data, the upper limit on an X-Bar or R-Chart
must be set at no more than 1.645 standard deviations of the statistic plotted
for a one-sided statistical comparison or at no more than 1.96 standard
deviations of the statistic plotted for a two-sided statistical
comparison.
6. For a verification
procedure consisting of discrete retests, the statistical method used shall be
the same as the method used in the initial statistical comparison.
Notwithstanding any provision of subsection (e)(9) of this section, the
critical value for the tests shall be chosen so that the Type I error rate for
all individual monitoring point comparisons is the same, whether for an initial
test or for a retest, and is equal-to-or-greater-than either 1-0.
95
1/(mws))
0.5 x
(1/r)
0.5
or
1-(.99)1/6
whichever is larger, where: m = the number of monitoring
parameters; w = the number of monitoring points at the waste management units;
s = the number of times that suites of monitoring data from the waste
management unit are subjected to initial statistical analysis within a period
of six months (i.e., s >= 1); and r = the number of discrete retests that
are to be conducted at a monitoring point whose initial statistical analysis
for a given constituent of concern or monitoring parameter has indicated the
presence of a release (i.e., r >= 2).
7. The owner or operator shall report to the
Department by certified mail the results of both the initial statistical test
and the results of the verification procedure as well as all concentration data
collected for use in these tests within seven days of the last laboratory
analysis of the samples collected for the verification procedure.
8. The verification procedure shall only be
performed for the constituent(s) which has shown statistically significant
evidence of a release, and shall only be performed for that (those) monitoring
point at which a release has been indicated.
(9) Each statistical method chosen under
subsection (e)(7) of this section for specification in the facility permit
shall comply with the following performance standards for each six-month
period.
(A) The statistical method used to
evaluate water quality monitoring data shall be appropriate for the
distribution of the constituent of concern or monitoring parameter to which it
is applied and shall be the least likely of the appropriate methods to fail to
identify a release from the regulated unit. If the distribution of a
constituent of concern or monitoring parameter is shown by the owner or
operator to be inappropriate for a normal theory test, then the data shall be
either transformed so that the distribution of the transformed data is
appropriate for a normal theory test or a distribution-free theory test shall
be used. If the distributions for the constituents of concern or monitoring
parameters differ, more than one statistical method may be needed.
(B) If an individual monitoring point
comparison procedure is used to compare an individual monitoring point
constituent concentration or monitoring parameter value with a concentration
limit in the water quality protection standard or with a background monitoring
parameter value, the test shall be done at a Type I error level no less than
0.01. If a multiple comparisons procedure is used, the Type I experiment-wise
error rate shall be no less than 0.05; however, the Type I error of no less
than 0.01 for individual monitoring point comparison shall be maintained. This
performance standard does not apply to tolerance intervals, prediction
intervals or control charts.
(C) If
a control chart approach is used to evaluate water quality monitoring data, the
specific type of control chart and its associated statistical parameter values
(e.g., the upper control limit) shall be proposed by the owner or operator and
approved by the Department if the Department finds it to be protective of human
health and the environment. Any control charting procedure must have a
false-positive rate of no less than one percent for each monitoring point
charted (e.g., upper control limits on X-bar or R-charts, used only once every
six months, must be set at no more than 2.327 standard deviations of the
statistic plotted for a one-sided statistical comparison or at no more than
2.576 standard deviations of the statistic plotted for a two-sided statistical
comparison).
(D) If a tolerance
interval or a prediction interval is used to evaluate water quality monitoring
data, the levels of confidence and, for tolerance intervals, the percentage of
the population that the interval must contain shall be proposed by the owner or
operator and approved by the Department if the Department finds these
statistical parameters to be protective of human health and the environment.
These statistical parameters shall be determined after considering the number
of samples in the background data base, the data distribution, and the range of
the concentrations or values for each constituent of concern or monitoring
parameter. The coverage of any tolerance interval used must be no more than 95
percent and the confidence coefficient must be no more than 95 percent for a
six-month period. Prediction intervals shall be constructed with an
experimentwise error rate of no less than five percent and an individual
monitoring point error rate of no less than one percent.
(E) The statistical method shall account for
data below the practical quantitation limit with one or more statistical
procedures that are protective of human health and the environment. Any
practical quantitation limit approved by the Department pursuant to subsection
(e)(7) of this section that is used in the statistical method shall be the
lowest concentration (or value) that can be reliably achieved within limits of
precision and accuracy specified in the facility permit for routine laboratory
operating conditions that are available to the facility.
(F) If necessary, the statistical methods
shall include procedures to control or correct for seasonal and spatial
variability as well as temporal correlation in the data.
(G) Any quality control procedure that is
approved by the Department for application to water quality data from
downgradient monitoring points for a monitored medium shall also be applied to
all newly-acquired background data from that medium. Any newly-acquired
background monitoring datum that is rejected by an approved quality control
procedure shall be maintained in the facility record but shall be excluded from
use in statistical comparisons with downgradient water quality
data.
(10) Based on the
data collected pursuant to subsection (e)(6) of this section and the
statistical methods proposed under subsection (e)(7) of this section, the owner
or operator shall propose and justify the use of a procedure for determining a
background value for each constituent of concern and for each monitoring
parameter specified in the facility permit. These procedures shall be proposed
for groundwater, surface water and the unsaturated zone. The owner or operator
shall propose one of the following for approval by the Department:
(A) a procedure for determining the
background value for each constituent or parameter that does not display
appreciable natural variation; or
(B) a procedure for establishing and updating
the background value for a constituent or parameter to reflect changes in the
background water quality if the use of contemporaneous or pooled data provides
the greatest power to the statistical method for that constituent or
paramenter.
(11) Upon
approval of the procedures for determining background values proposed pursuant
to subsection (e)(10) of this section, the Department shall specify in the
facility permit one of the following for each constituent of concern and for
each monitoring parameter:
(A) the background
value established by the owner or operator using the procedure proposed
pursuant to subsection (e)(10)(A) of this section; or
(B) a detailed description of the procedure
to be used by the owner or operator for establishing and updating the
background value as proposed pursuant to subsection (e)(10)(B) of this
section.
(12) For each
constituent of concern and monitoring parameter listed in the facility permit,
the owner or operator shall propose, for approval by the Department, the
sampling methods to be used to establish background values and the sampling
methods to be used for monitoring pursuant to this article. Upon final approval
by the Department, sampling methods consistent with the following shall be
specified in the facility permit.
(A) The
number and kinds of samples collected shall be appropriate for the form of
statistical test employed, following generally accepted statistical principles.
The sample size shall be as large as necessary to ensure with reasonable
confidence that:
1. for a detection
monitoring program, a release from the regulated unit will be
detected;
2. for an evaluation
monitoring program, changes in water quality due to a release from the
regulated unit will be recognized; and
3. for a corrective action program,
compliance with the water quality protection standard and effectiveness of the
corrective action program will be determined.
(B) The sampling method (including the
sampling frequency and the interval of time between successive samples) shall
be appropriate for the medium from which samples are taken (i.e., groundwater,
surface water and soil-pore liquid). The sampling method shall include one of
the following:
1. the collection of not less
than one sample quarterly from each monitoring point and background monitoring
point and statistical analysis performed at least quarterly; or
2. a sequence of at least four samples
collected at least semi-annually from each monitoring point and each background
monitoring point and statistical analysis performed at least semi-annually.
Samples shall be taken at an interval that assures, to the greatest extent
possible, that an independent sample is obtained. The Department shall require
more frequent sampling and statistical analysis when necessary to protect human
health and the environment. For groundwater, the sampling frequency and the
interval between successive sampling events shall be based upon the rate of
groundwater flow, and upon any variation in groundwater flow rate and
direction. The rate of groundwater movement shall be calculated by reference to
the aquifer's effective porosity, hydraulic conductivity and hydraulic
gradient; or
3. an alternate
sampling method. Alternate collection and analysis frequencies may be proposed
by the owner or operator for approval by the
Department.
(13) The groundwater portion of the
monitoring program shall include an accurate determination of the groundwater
surface elevation and field parameters (temperature, electrical conductivity,
turbidity and pH) at each well each time groundwater is sampled. Field
parameter determinations may be modified or waived, after receiving written
approval by the Department, if the owner or operator can demonstrate that
representative samples are obtained. Any modifications to field parameter
determinations shall be specified in the monitoring and response
program.
(14) The owner or operator
shall graph all analytical data from each monitoring point and background
monitoring point and shall submit these graphs to the Department at least
annually, except graphs are not required for constituents for which no new data
have been collected since the previous graph submittal. Each graph shall
represent data for one constituent of concern or monitoring parameter and shall
be at a scale appropriate to show trends or variations in water quality. Unless
the owner or operator receives written approval from the Department to use an
alternate procedure, each graph shall include data from related monitoring and
background points as long as the depicted data effectively illustrates trends
or variations in the data.
(15) In
addition to the water quality sampling conducted pursuant to the requirements
of this article, the owner or operator shall measure the water level in each
well and determine groundwater flow rate and direction in the uppermost aquifer
and in any zones of perched water and in any additional aquifers monitored
pursuant to subsection (b)(1) of this section at least quarterly, including the
times of expected highest and lowest elevations of the water levels in the
wells. However, based on site-specific conditions, the Department may approve
an alternate frequency of at least annually. The owner or operator using an
approved alternative sampling frequency shall, based on available groundwater
data, determine, at least annually, whether the requirements of section
66264.97(b)(1)
are satisfied. If the evaluation shows that the requirements of section
66264.97(b)(1)
are not satisfied, the owner or operator shall submit to the Department an
application for a permit modification to make the appropriate changes to modify
the number, location or depth of the groundwater monitoring wells as necessary
to bring the groundwater monitoring system into compliance with the
requirements of this article.
(16)
Water quality monitoring data collected in accordance with this article,
including actual values of constituents and parameters, shall be maintained in
the facility operating record. The Department shall specify in the permit when
the data shall be submitted for review.