Year and a day quotation

Show on page(s): 

"This case concerns the constitutionality of the retroactive application of a judicial decision abolishing the common law 'year and a day rule.'  At common law, the year and a day rule provided that no defendant could be convicted of murder unless his victim had died by the defendant's act within a year and a day of the act. . . .  The Supreme Court of Tennessee abolished the rule as it had existed at common law in Tennessee and applied its decision to petitioner to uphold his conviction.  The question before us is whether, in doing so, the court denied petitioner due process of law in violation of the Fourteenth Amendment."

"There is . . . nothing to indicate that the Tennessee court's abolition of the rule in petitioner's case represented an exercise of the sort of unfair and arbitrary judicial action against which the Due Process Clause aims to protect.  Far from a marked and unpredictable departure from prior precedent, the court's decision was a routine exercise of common law decisionmaking in which the court brought the law into conformity with reason and common sense. It did so by laying to rest an archaic and outdated rule that had never been relied upon as a ground of decision in any reported Tennessee case."