Analysis of resonance reliability for synchronousbelt transmission with transverse vibration
Ruijun Zhang^{1} , Xinxin Si^{2} , Weiwei Yang^{3} , Nannan Wang^{4}
^{1, 2, 3, 4}Shandong Jianzhu University, Jinan, 250101, China
^{1, 4}Key Laboratory of Mechanical Engineering and Innovation Technology in Universities of Shandong Shandong Jianzhu University, Jinan, 250101, China
^{1}Corresponding author
Journal of Vibroengineering, Vol. 16, Issue 2, 2014, p. 891900.
Received 14 November 2013; received in revised form 6 January 2014; accepted 23 January 2014; published 31 March 2014
JVE Conferences
Against the resonance reliability problem of synchronous belt transmission with random parameters, the synchronous belt transmission is modeled as the continuum of axial movement. The frequency response of synchronous belt with transverse vibration is analyzed based on the Galerkin method. Considering the randomness of the parameters, the relationship between frequency response and random parameters is derived from the perturbation theory. On basis of the structure fatigue at resonance, the performance function of the resonance reliability of the synchronous belt transmission is achieved by using the criterion between natural frequency and excitation frequency, which research the first two order resonance failure probability of synchronous belt transmission. The result shows that with the increase of belt speed, the natural frequency of transverse vibration for synchronousbelt transmission is lowered. The first resonance failure probability is decreased, while the second resonance failure probability is increased. The results provide a reference for antiresonance design and reliability assessment of belt transmission.
Keywords: transverse vibration, synchronousbelt transmission, resonance, random parameters reliability.
1. Introduction
Belt transmission is widely used in engineering. Transverse vibration, longitudinal vibration and torsional vibration will be induced in the process of transmission, which will have a serious impact on transmission characteristics of belt transmission [1]. Especially, it will influence the transmission behaviors of the transmission system and even leads to the vibration failure of the conveyor belts when the natural frequencies of the conveyor belts are close to the eccentric vibration frequencies of the pulleys. Thereby it will affect the reliability of the belt transmission. Therefore, it is necessary to analyze the reliability of the belt transmission. In recent years, many researchers have conducted intensive research about the vibration characteristics of belt transmission. Serge Abrate [2] researched the mechanics model of free and forced vibration for belt transmission, and analyzed the effect of initial tension, belt speed and bending rigidity on the vibration characteristics of belt transmission. J. Moon [3] studied nonlinear vibration of belt transmission through experiments and theories. Tokoro and Nakamura [4] researched the transverse vibration of synchronous belt and analyzed the impact of fluctuation cycle of tension on transverse vibration using experimental methods. Riedel [5] studied the relationship between the ratio of the firstorder frequency and the secondorder frequency of conveyor belts and the axially velocity of belts. Yang Yu Ping [6] analyzed the effect of the axially velocity and applied tension on the natural frequencies of transverse vibration for synchronousbelt. Taking the flexible effects of belt into consideration, Yao Ting Qiang [7] studied dynamic responses of belt transmission such as transversal vibration; bend moment of belt and so on. Ge Xin Sheng [8] established the nonlinear vibration equation of axially stripe based on the Galerkin method, researched the effect of axially velocity and applied tension on the transverse and longitudinal vibration of belt transmission with the method of numerical simulation. However, the parameters of belt transmission and excitation loads were all regarded as deterministic parameters in these papers. Obviously, it did not reflect the impact of the random factors on dynamic response in the transmission process. Actually, the uncertainty of parameters (example: bending stiffness, unit mass and belt speed) will result in the uncertainty of vibration characteristics (vibration displacement, frequency) of belt transmission. Meanwhile, it also makes that the appearance of resonance for belt transmission becomes a random event under specified conditions and times. Therefore, the issues of random parameters of belt transmission resonance reliability are studied, which has important significance for the safety assessment of belt transmission. In terms of belt transmission reliability, Tan Ling [9] treated design parameters in belt transmission as random variables and analyzed the reliability based on the sufficient fatigue life and nosliding of belt transmission, but ignoring the effect of shock of belt on reliability of belt transmission. On the study of structure resonance reliability, Zhang Yi Min [10] adopted random perturbation technique to study the frequency reliability of rotor system. Zhai Hong Bo [11] used the point estimation method and the modified Edgeworth expansion to calculate the resonance reliabilities of a pipe conveying fluid. Hou Zhi Chao [12] systematically conducted the sensitivity analysis on natural frequencies of the multiribbed belt drive. But the studies about analyses of resonance reliability based on the dynamics of belt transmission are still relatively less. In view of the above studies, taking synchronousbelt transmission as an example, considering the randomness of parameters and excitation loads of synchronousbelt transmission, combining the Galerkin method and perturbation theory, the resonance reliability of synchronousbelt transmission is analyzed. In addition, the effects of the belt speed on the first two order resonance failure probability of synchronousbelt transmission is discussed.
2. The transverse vibration model of synchronousbelt transmission
Synchronousbelt transmission is a mesh transmission and transmits power through meshing between the toothed and the cogging, which can achieve nosliding transmission and has accurate transmission ratio and high transmission efficiency. Currently, the synchronous belt transmission is widely used in the mechanical transmission of various industries and types, for example: the textile machinery, machine tools [13], automobile, shipbuilding [14] and so on.
The transverse vibration of synchronousbelt transmission mainly occurs in the line segment between two pulleys. Since the sectional dimension of synchronousbelt is smaller than the center distance between two pulleys and the flexural rigidity of synchronousbelt, the transverse vibration model of Synchronousbelt Transmission can be approximately simplified to the transverse vibration of chord, in which the length of the chord is partial length of line between two pulleys [1].
Beikmann [15, 16] simplified the belt to axial movement chord by ignoring the bending stiffness of belt. Zhang [1719] applied the model which Beikmann had established to calculate the characteristic values of transverse vibration for belt transmission. According to the model of reference [15], the transverse vibration model of synchronousbelt is established.
To describe the transverse vibration of synchronousbelt transmission, the tangent point between synchronousbelt and the pitch circle of big pulley is set to coordinate origin, and the equilibrium position of transverse vibration of synchronousbelt transmission is set to the $x$axis. The coordinate system $xou$ is depicted in Fig. 1.
Considering the synchronousbelt speed, $c$ is the transverse vibration damping of belt; $L$ is the span of the synchronousbelt between big pulley and small pulley; $\rho $ is the mass per unit length of the synchronousbelt; $EI$ is the bending rigidity; $T$ is the applied tension; $v$ is the belt speed; $u(x,t)$ is the transverse displacement. Considering transverse vibration of the synchronous belt in plan, the crosswise vibration equation is established as follows:
Fig. 1. The transverse vibration model of synchronousbelt transmission
The boundary conditions are as follows:
3. Frequency response analysis of synchronousbelt based on Galerkin method
The equation of synchronousbelt transverse vibration is high order partial differential equation with homogeneous boundary conditions, so it is difficult to find the exact solutions. Therefore, the Eq. (1) has to be solved approximately utilizing the Galerkin method [20]. For the transverse vibration model of a simply supported synchronousbelt transmission, the sine function sequence satisfies the boundary conditions. Sine function is regarded as the trial function of Galerkin method, i.e.:
where ${b}_{n}$ is the defining coefficient, $N$ is the order of Galerkin truncated. In order to improve the calculation accuracy, the weight function is equal to the trial function, i.e.:
Substituting the trial function into original functions, then residual value is obtained:
If the inner product of the residual and the weight function satisfies the orthogonality, the residual can be eliminated, so:
Residual and the weight function are substituted into the Eq. (7), so:
where:
Eq. (8) can be written as matrix form:
where, the elements in ${A}_{n}$ are shown as follows:
$\left(\rho {v}^{2}T\right){\left(\frac{n\pi}{L}\right)}^{2}{f}_{1}\left(n,k\right).$
The coefficient matrix is ${A}_{n}$, the sufficient and necessary condition for Eq. (9) with nonzero solutions is:
where, $T(\omega ,X)$ is a polynomial about the structure parameters and natural frequency. Due to the element ${a}_{n,k}$ in the coefficient matrix ${A}_{n}$ containing plural entries, so the equation has plural roots. Omitted the roots of the expired real part with a negative portion, the real part of the roots are the natural frequencies of synchronousbelt transverse vibration.
4. Analysis of resonance reliability for synchronousbelt transmission
Considering the randomness of parameters of synchronousbelt transmission and according to Eqn. (10), the natural frequency of synchronousbelt transmission also has the randomness. Therefore, the appearance of resonance for belt transmission becomes a random event. Meanwhile, the appropriate probability is needed to avoid resonance of the designed synchronousbelt transmission system when analyzing its reliability.
4.1. Relationship between random frequency response and random parameters
$X={({x}_{1},{x}_{2},...,{x}_{j})}^{T}$ is the random parameters of the synchronousbelt transmission. According to the random perturbation theory [21], the vector of random parameters $X$ and the natural frequency are expressed as follows:
where, $\epsilon $ is a small parameter; the part expressed by subscript $d$ is the certain part of the random parameters; the part expressed by subscript $p$ is the random part and has a zero mean value in the random parameters.
Substituting the random parameters into Eq. (10), we obtain $T({\omega}_{d},{X}_{d})=0$. The function $T({\omega}_{d},{X}_{d})=0$ is carried on multivariate Taylor series expansion at the point $({\omega}_{d}+\epsilon {\omega}_{p},{X}_{d}+\epsilon {X}_{p})$. By eliminating highorder terms, we obtain:
where, $\frac{\partial T}{\partial X}=\sum _{i=1}^{n}\frac{\partial T}{\partial {x}_{i}}$, $\frac{{\partial}^{2}T}{\partial {X}^{2}}=\sum _{i=1}^{n}\sum _{j=1}^{n}\frac{\partial T}{\partial {x}_{i}\partial {x}_{j}}$.
Due to random part having zero mean value and according to Eq. (12), the mean value of natural frequency is obtained as follows:
Finally according to the Eq. (10) and Eq. (14), the relationship between random frequency response and random parameters is expressed as follows:
Substituting the random parameters into Eqn. (10), $\omega \left(X\right)$ can be obtained.
4.2. Analysis of resonance failure for synchronousbelt transmission
Resonance reliability of synchronousbelt transmission refers to the satisfaction extent between natural frequency and excitation frequency under specified conditions and time. The guideline [22] for stability of vibrations stipulates: the natural frequency and the excitation frequency usually meet the following relationship:
where, $f$ is the excitation frequency, $\omega $ is the natural frequency.
The relation between the natural frequency of the synchronousbelt affected by excitation and the excitation frequency of the synchronous pulley (the excitation frequency $f=2n\pi /60$, $n$ is the velocity of the pulley) should satisfy the Eq. (17). In addition, the velocities of two synchronous pulleys are different in the synchronousbelt transmission, so do the eccentric excitation frequencies of two synchronous pulleys. In order to avoid occurring resonance for the synchronous belt transmission, according to Eq. (17), the natural frequencies of synchronousbelt are less than the excitation frequency of large pulley, or the natural frequencies of synchronousbelt are greater than the excitation frequency of small pulley.
Thus, on basis of the structure fatigue at resonance, according to the analysis of natural frequencies for synchronousbelt transverse vibration and the guideline of stability of vibrations, the performance function of the resonance reliability of synchronousbelt transmission is defined as follows:
where, $\omega \left(X\right)$ is the natural frequency of synchronousbelt and is the function about random parameters $X$. ${f}_{1}$ is the excitation frequency of large pulley. ${f}_{2}$ is the excitation frequency of small pulley, and ${f}_{1}<{f}_{2}$.
According to the relationship between the natural frequencies and the excitation frequency, the failure state of the synchronousbelt transmission when producing resonance can be determined, i.e.:
Assume that the natural frequency and excitation frequency of synchronousbelt transmission obey normal distribution independently, according to the digital characteristic values of random variable, the mean value and variance of the Eq. (18) are expressed as follows:
where:
where, ${\mu}_{{f}_{1}}$ and ${\sigma}_{{f}_{1}}^{2}$ are the mean value and variance of big pulley respectively, ${\mu}_{{f}_{2}}$ and ${\sigma}_{{f}_{2}}^{2}$ are the mean value and variance of small pulley respectively.
The resonance reliability index is defined as follows:
So the reliability is $R=\mathrm{\Phi}\left(\beta \right)$, the failure probability is $P=1R$, where, $\mathrm{\Phi}(\cdot )$ is the standard normal distribution function.
5. Numerical examples
The model of synchronousbelt transmission transverse vibration of a machine is shown in Fig. 1. Here, the parameters are given : the span of synchronousbelt $L=\text{1}\text{}\text{m}$, the bending rigidity of the synchronousbelt $EI=\text{9.628\xd7}{\text{10}}^{\text{3}}\text{}\text{N}{\text{m}}^{\text{3}}$, applied tension of synchronousbelt $T=\text{125}\text{}\text{N}$, the mass per unit length of synchronousbelt $\rho =\text{0.095}\text{}\text{kg/m}$, rotational speed of big pulley ${n}_{1}=\text{200}\text{}\text{rad/s}$, and rotational speed of small pulley ${n}_{2}=\text{1000}\text{}\text{rad/s}$. This article tries to determine the first two order resonance failure probability of synchronousbelt transmission when the synchronousbelt speed are $\text{0}\text{}\text{m/s}$,$\text{10}\text{}\text{m/s}$ and $\text{20}\text{}\text{m/s}$ respectively.
5.1. Calculated of the natural frequency for synchronousbelt based on Galerkin method
In order to calculate the first three order natural frequency of transverse vibration for synchronousbelt transmission, according to the contents in Section 2, the trial function and the weight function of Galerkin method are expressed respectively as follows:
Substituting the trial function into the Eq. (1), we can obtain the residual value. According to the Eq. (7)(9), finally the elements in ${A}_{n}$ are shown as follows:
Fig. 2. The curves of belt speed and the first three natural frequencies
Substituting the known conditions into the expressed of the elements and according to the Eq. (10), the first three natural frequency of synchronousbelt transmission can be obtained. The contrast of calculation results between method of this paper and the proposed method of the literature [6] are shown in Table 1, the change curve of the first three orders natural frequencies of transverse vibration of the synchronousbelt along with the belt speed are shown in Fig. 2.
Table 1. The contrast of calculation results
Velocity

First order frequency

Second order frequency

Third order frequency


This paper’s Galerkin method

0 m/s

114.0

228.26

343.04

10 m/s

103.67

217.64

330.46


20 m/s

75.16

176.52

306.26


Variable separation method [6]

0 m/s

114.0

228.26

343.04

10 m/s

109.59

219.44

329.84


20 m/s

95.12

190.56

286.61

5.2. Calculated of the resonance failure probability based on parameters randomness
According to the known conditions, the random parameters are defined as $X={(E,I,\rho ,v,T)}^{T}$. Each random parameter can be expressed as ${x}_{j}={x}_{jd}+\epsilon {x}_{jp}$, $j=\text{1,}\text{}\text{2,}\text{}\text{3,}\text{}\text{4,}\text{}\text{5}$ and $\epsilon =\text{1}$.
According to the elements of coefficient matrix in Section 4.1 and the Eq. (10), the random polynomial is expressed as $T(\omega ,X)={a}_{\mathrm{1,1}}\times {a}_{\mathrm{2,2}}{a}_{\mathrm{2,1}}\times {a}_{\mathrm{1,2}}$.
Fig. 3. The curves of synchronousbelt speed and the failure probability of synchronousbelt transmission
Table 2. Distribution patterns and parameters of random variables
Random variables

Distribution patterns

Mean value

Variance

Applied tension / (N)

Normal distribution

125

6.25

The excitation frequency of big pulley / ($\text{rad/s}$)

Normal distribution

20.93

1.05

The excitation frequency of small pulley / ($\text{rad/s}$)

Normal distribution

104.67

5.23

Elastic modulus of synchronousbelt / ($\text{pa}$)

Normal distribution

2.5e^{10}

1.25e^{9}

Moment of inertia / (${\text{m}}^{\text{2}}$)

Normal distribution

9.63e^{13}

3.85e^{13}

The mass per unit length of the synchronousbelt / (kg/m)

Normal distribution

9.5e^{2}

4.75e^{3}

Belt speed / (m/s)

Normal distribution

0

0

10

0.5


20

1

Table 3. Results of resonance reliability analysis for synchronousbelt transmission
Velocity

First order resonance failure probability / ${P}_{1}$

Second order resonance failure probability / ${P}_{2}$

0 m/s

0.001095

0.055417

10 m/s

0.000845

0.066823

20 m/s

0.000561

0.087146

We analyze the random characteristics of natural frequency of transverse vibration for synchronousbelt transmission based on the Eq. (15) and the Eq. (16). Finally, according the Eq. (18), (19) and $P=1R$, the first two order failure probability is obtained. The distribution patterns and parameters of random variables are shown in Table 2. Employing Matlab, the result is shown in Table 3 when the synchronousbelt speed is $\text{0}\text{}\text{m/s}$, $\text{10}\text{}\text{m/s}$ and $\text{20}\text{}\text{m/s}$ respectively. The curves of changes for the first two order resonance failure probability along with belt speed are shown in Fig. 3.
5.3. Discussion and analysis
(1) As can be seen through Table 1, the first three order natural frequencies obtained respectively by the Galerkin method and the proposed method of the literature [6] are reducing along with the belt speed increasing, and there exists some differences between the results. When the belt speed is zero, the first three order natural frequencies calculated by both methods are the same. It is shown that both methods have the better accuracy when the velocity is zero, but the differences between the results obtained by both methods are also increasing along with the belt speed increasing. The reason for that is the truncation orders of Galerkin method improve the accuracy of natural frequency. From Fig. 2 we can see that with the axial velocity of synchronousbelt increasing, the natural frequency of transverse vibration for synchronousbelt transmission reduces, because the increasing of synchronousbelt speed reduces the rigidity of synchronousbelt and further causes the decrease of the natural frequency of synchronousbelt.
(2) From Fig. 3 we can see that with the increase of synchronousbelt speed, the first resonance failure probability of synchronousbelt transmission decreases, and the second resonance failure probability of synchronousbelt transmission increases, because the increase of synchronousbelt speed reduces the natural frequencies of synchronousbelt. In other words, it causes the first natural frequencies of synchronousbelt to stay away from the range of the excitation frequencies of synchronous pulleys and the second natural frequencies of synchronousbelt to near the range of the excitation frequencies of synchronous pulleys. Thus it leads to the change of resonance failure probability of synchronousbelt transmission.
(3) In this paper, the numerical example is analyzed, which can effectively verify the correctness of the built model and the feasibility of the proposed method. Moreover, through the numerical example analysis, this method is also applicable to the other belt transmission system which can be modeled as the continuum of axial movement.
6. Conclusions
In this paper, the natural frequencies of transverse vibration of synchronousbelt are solved to verify the effectiveness of Galerkin method. Simultaneously considering the randomness of parameters, the performance function of the resonance reliability of synchronousbelt transmission is established based on the criterion of vibration stability, which can better reflect the resonance failure state of synchronousbelt transmission at the actual work to ensure the natural frequency deviate from the excitation frequency with reasonable probability. From the perspective of reliability theory, the resonance failure of synchronousbelt transmission is studied, which can provide a reference for the resonance prevention and parameters optimized of belt transmission.
Acknowledgements
This project is supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 51075244).
References
 Luo Shan Ming, Yu Yi Dao, Guo Ying Fu, et al. Theory of belt transmission and new type of belt transmission. First Edition, National Defense Industry Press, Beijing, 2006. [Search CrossRef]
 Serge Abrate Vibration of belts and belt drives. Mechanism and Machine Theory, Vol. 6, Issue 27, 1992, p. 645659. [Search CrossRef]
 Moon J., Wickert J. A. Nonlinear vibration of power transmission belts. Journal of Sound and Vibration, Vol. 4, Issue 200, 1997, p. 419431. [Search CrossRef]
 Tokoro H., Nakamura M., Sugiura N. Analysis of transverse vibration in engine timing belt. JSAE Review, Vol. 1, Issue 18, 1997, p. 3338. [Search CrossRef]
 Riedel C. H., Tan C. A. Coupled, forced response of an axially moving strip with internal resonance. International Journal of NonLinear Mechanics, Vol. 37, 2000, p. 101116. [Search CrossRef]
 Yang Yuping, Zhang Xiaomei, Shen Shide Analysis and research on the transverse vibration of synchronous belt transmission system. Journal of Machine Design, Vol. 1, Issue 20, 2003, p. 2830, (in Chinese). [Search CrossRef]
 Yao Tingqiang, Chi Yilin, Huang Yayu, Tan Yang Research on multibody dynamics and contact vibration of belt transmission. Journal of System Simulation, Vol. 16, Issue 21, 2009, p. 49454950, (in Chinese). [Search CrossRef]
 Ge XinSheng, Li DeShuang Nonlinear vibration of axially moving strip with the transverse and longitudinal. Journal of Mechanical Strength, Vol. 1, Issue 34, 2012, p. 020024, (in Chinese). [Search CrossRef]
 Qin Ling, Xie Junsheng, Liang Dongcheng Reliability optimization design of hydraulically automatic lathe Vbelt transmission. Mechanical Transmission, Vol. 6, Issue 32, 2008, p. 6467, (in Chinese). [Search CrossRef]
 Zhang Yimin, Su Changqing, Wen Bangchun Natural frequency reliability analysis of rotor system. Journal of Vibration Engineering, Vol. 2, Issue 22, 2009, p. 218220, (in Chinese). [Search CrossRef]
 Zhai Hongbo, Wu Ziyan, Liu Yongshou, Yye Zhufeng Analysis of resonance reliability for a simply supported pipe conveying fluid. Journal of Vibration and Shock, Vol. 12, Issue 31, 2012, p. 160164, (in Chinese). [Search CrossRef]
 Hou Zhichao, Wang Xiangwu, Lao Yaoxin Frequency sensitivity analysis of multiribbed belt drive systems. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, Vol. 11, Issue 45, 2009, p. 235239, (in Chinese). [Search CrossRef]
 Fang WenZhong Design manufacture and use of synchronous belt transmission. First Edition, Shanghai Popular Science Press, Shanghai, 1993. [Search CrossRef]
 Peng Lei Application of synchronous belt drive on air cushion craft. Ship and Boat, Vol. 3, Issue 23, 2012, p. 4549, (in Chinese). [Search CrossRef]
 Beikmann R. S., Perkins N. C., Ulsoy A. G. Free vibration of serpentine belt drive systems. ASME J. Vib. Acoust., Vol. 3, Issue 118, 1996, p. 406413. [Search CrossRef]
 Beikmann R. S., Perkins N. C., Ulsoy A. G. Design and analysis of automotive serpentine belt drive systems for steady state performance. ASME J. Mech. Des., Vol. 3, Issue 119, 1996, p. 162168. [Search CrossRef]
 Zhang L., Zu J. W. Modal analysis of serpentine belt drive systems. ASME J. Vib. Acoust., Vol. 2, Issue 222, 1999, p. 259279. [Search CrossRef]
 Zhang L. X., Zu J. W. Onetoone autoparametric resonances in serpentine belt drive systems. J. Sound. Vib., Issue 232, 2000, p. 783806. [Search CrossRef]
 Zhang L. X., Zu J. W., Hou Z. C. Complex modal analysis of nonselfad joint hybrid serpentine belt drive systems. ASME J. Vib. Acoust., Issue 123, 2001, p. 150156. [Search CrossRef]
 Lao Dazhong Fundamentals of the calculus of variations. First Edition, National Defense Industry Press, Beijing, 2004. [Search CrossRef]
 Su Changqing, Zhang Yimin, Ma Hui Reliability sensitivity analysis for crack propagation of rotating shaft. Journal of Aerospace Power, Vol. 4, Issue 24, 2009, p. 810814, (in Chinese). [Search CrossRef]
 Qin Datong, Xie Liyang Modern design manual. Sixth Volume, Chemical Industry Press, Beijing, 2011. [Search CrossRef]