A. Any
modification, alteration, enlargement, or major repair of an existing dam,
whether requested by the owner or directed by the Commission, will be subject
to the current design standards for the appropriate hazard classification as
set forth in this regulation.
B.
High Hazard dams must be capable of safely passing the runoff from a 24 hour
duration 100-year rainfall event through the principal spillway without
activating the auxiliary (emergency) spillway. The 100- year rainfall event is
established by the National Weather Service Atlas 14 and varies for different
areas of the state. The runoff from one hundred percent (100%) of the 24 hour
Probable Maximum Precipitation (PMP), as defined in Rule
3.1. of this regulation, must be passed
through the principal and auxiliary (emergency) spillway and/or stored in the
reservoir without overtopping the dam unless an incremental consequence
analysis as defined in Rule 3.5 E. of this regulation indicates a lesser inflow
design flood is applicable. The appropriate PMP for each county as obtained
from NOAA HMR 51 and the hyetograph (Natural Resource Conservation Service
Spillway Emergency Distribution) to be used in design routings are provided in
Appendix A of this regulation.
C.
Significant hazard dams must be capable of safely passing and /or storing the
runoff from at least fifty percent (50%) of the 24 hour PMP without overtopping
the dam unless an incremental consequence analysis as defined in Rule 3.5 E. of
this regulation indicates a lesser inflow design flood is applicable. The owner
and any other persons responsible for the construction and operation of the dam
shall assume all risks for future costs to upgrade a dam in the event the
hazard classification change.
D.
Low hazard dams must be capable of safely passing and/or storing the runoff
from either the 24 hour duration 100-year rainfall for the dam location
according to NOAA Atlas 14 or thirty-five percent (35%) of the 24 hour PMP
without overtopping the dam. The owner and any other persons responsible for
the construction and operation of the dam shall assume all risks for future
costs to upgrade a dam in the event the hazard classification
changes.
E. An inflow design flood
based on Incremental Consequence Analysis (ICA) may be developed and submitted
to MDEQ. The analysis shall be conducted in accordance with
MDEQ
Acceptable Procedures for Conducting an Incremental Consequence
Analysis; a copy of which may be obtained by contacting the MDEQ Dam
Safety Division. MDEQ will review the ICA to determine whether the spillway
design criteria for high and significant hazard dams, stated at Rule 3.5 B. and
C. of these regulations, may be modified based on the ICA. The range of inflow
design floods that can be considered as part of an ICA are as defined in the
table below.
|
Hazard Classification
|
ICA Inflow Design Flood
|
|
High
|
50-100% PMP
|
|
Significant
|
500 year - 50% PMP
|
Any future changes in downstream land use, development, or
critical hydraulic structures will require a re-evaluation of the incremental
consequences and could require additional increases in spillway capacity for
the dam. The owner and any other persons responsible for the operation of the
dam shall assume all risks for future costs to upgrade a dam in the event there
is a change in incremental consequences. Consequences shall be re-evaluated
when changes occur but no less frequently than once every 5 years during a
formal inspection of the dam.
F. When a conduit is proposed to be used in a
high or significant hazard dam, the professional engineer responsible for the
project shall provide MDEQ with detailed hydraulic, hydrologic, and structural
computations supporting selection of the size and type of pipe to be used.
Detailed drawings and specifications relating to the installation of the pipe
shall include, but not be limited to, construction measures that adequately
address critical loading, bedding, backfill, compaction, and seepage
precautions related to installation of the pipe.
G. All concrete structures shall be designed
in accordance with the applicable design standards in place at the time of
construction. Details, as necessary, shall be provided showing reinforcement,
cut offs, under drains/filters, waterstops, construction joints, control
joints, and any other details necessary to construct.
H. The use of corrugated metal pipe for any
purpose is expressly prohibited for high and significant hazard dams, because
corrugated metal pipe typically experiences severe corrosion and fails long
before its expected design life.
I.
The use of geotextiles in filters is expressly prohibited for high and
significant hazard dams, because, geotextiles will plug with native soil
material and make the filter inoperable.
J. The soils in an earthen auxiliary
(emergency) spillway shall be capable of withstanding the water velocities
generated when the auxiliary (emergency) spillway is activated without
experiencing excessive erosion. In order to demonstrate this a SITES Stability
and Integrity Analysis shall be performed for all new earthen spillways
proposed for high and significant hazard dams as well as all existing high and
significant hazard dam earthen spillways where major modifications are proposed
to any part of the dam.
K. Side
slopes of all dams shall be a minimum of three horizontal to one vertical
(3:1).
L. Seepage and slope
stability analysis may be required at the discretion of MDEQ.
M. Wave wash protection must be provided
along the upstream face of the dam or engineering justification proving it is
not necessary must be provided for the construction of all new high and
significant hazard dams.
N. Owners
of high hazard or significant hazard dams will be required to prohibit
livestock grazing on the dam in order to prevent damage to the turf and to
prevent erosion associated with establishment of animal trails.
O. Owners of earthen dams covered under this
regulation shall establish and maintain a healthy turf on the exposed faces of
the dam to prevent erosion, and shall mow frequently enough to prevent the
encroachment of woody vegetation into the slopes of the dam embankment or
within the prescribed limits (generally 50 feet from the toe) set by
MDEQ.
P. Operation and Maintenance
manuals may be required for high and significant hazard dams at the discretion
of MDEQ.