(A)
Purpose
This rule sets forth requirements for
development and implementation of behavioral support strategies including both
positive measures and restrictive measures for the purpose of
ensuring:
(1)
Individuals with developmental disabilities are
supported in a caring and responsive manner that promotes dignity, respect, and
trust and with recognition that they are equal citizens with the same rights
and personal freedoms granted to Ohioans without developmental
disabilities;
(2)
An individual's services and supports are based on an
understanding of the individual and the reasons for the individual's
actions;
(3)
Effort is directed at creating opportunities for
individuals to exercise choice in matters affecting their everyday lives and
supporting individuals to make choices that yield positive outcomes;
and
(4)
Restrictive measures are used only when necessary to
keep people safe and always in conjunction with positive
measures.
(C)
Definitions
For the purposes of this rule, the
following definitions apply:
(1)
"Chemical restraint" means the use of medication in
accordance with scheduled dosing or pro re nata ("PRN" or as needed) for the
purpose of causing a general or non-specific blunt suppression of behavior
(i.e., the effect of the medication results in a noticeable or discernible
difference in the individual's ability to complete activities of daily living)
or for the purpose of treating sexual offending behavior.
(a)
A behavioral
support strategy may include chemical restraint only when an individual's
actions pose risk of harm or an individual engages in a precisely-defined
pattern of behavior that is very likely to result in risk of
harm.
(b)
A medication prescribed for the treatment of a physical
or psychiatric condition in accordance with the standards of treatment for that
condition and not for the purpose of causing a general or non-specific blunt
suppression of behavior, is presumed to not be a chemical
restraint.
(c)
"Chemical restraint" does not include a medication that
is routinely prescribed in conjunction with a medical procedure for patients
without developmental disabilities.
(2)
"County board"
means a county board of developmental disabilities.
(3)
"Department"
means the Ohio department of developmental disabilities.
(4)
"Director" means
the director of the Ohio department of developmental
disabilities.
(5)
"Emergency" means an individual's behavior presents an
immediate danger of physical harm to the individual or another person or the
individual being the subject of a legal sanction and all available positive
measures have proved ineffective or infeasible.
(6)
"Human rights
committee" means a standing committee formed by a county board or an
intermediate care facility for individuals with intellectual disabilities to
safeguard individuals' rights and protect individuals from physical, emotional,
and psychological harm. At an intermediate care facility for individuals with
intellectual disabilities, the human rights committee may also be referred to
as a "specially constituted committee" as that term is used in
42 C.F.R.
483.440 as in effect on the effective date of
this rule.
(7)
"Individual" means a person with a developmental
disability.
(8)
"Individual service plan" means the written description
of services, supports, and activities to be provided to an individual and
includes an "individual program plan" as that term is used in
42 C.F.R.
483.440 as in effect on the effective date of
this rule.
(9)
"Informed consent" means a documented written agreement
to allow a proposed action, treatment, or service after full disclosure
provided in a manner an individual or the individual's guardian, as applicable,
understands, of the relevant facts necessary to make the decision. Relevant
facts include the risks and benefits of the action, treatment, or service; the
risks and benefits of the alternatives to the action, treatment, or service;
and the right to refuse the action, treatment, or service. An individual or
guardian, as applicable, may withdraw informed consent at any
time.
(10)
"Intermediate care facility for individuals with
intellectual disabilities" has the same meaning as in section
5124.01 of the Revised
Code.
(11)
"Manual restraint" means use of a hands-on method, but
never in a prone restraint, to control an identified action by restricting the
movement or function of an individual's head, neck, torso, one or more limbs,
or entire body, using sufficient force to cause the possibility of injury and
includes holding or disabling an individual's wheelchair or other mobility
device.
(a)
A
behavioral support strategy may include manual restraint only when an
individual's actions pose risk of harm.
(b)
An individual in
a manual restraint shall be under constant visual supervision by
staff.
(c)
Manual restraint shall cease immediately once risk of
harm has passed.
(d)
"Manual restraint" does not include a method that is
routinely used during a medical procedure for patients without developmental
disabilities.
(12)
"Mechanical restraint" means use of a device, but never
in a prone restraint, to control an identified action by restricting an
individual's movement or function.
(a)
A behavioral support strategy may include mechanical
restraint only when an individual's actions pose risk of harm.
(b)
Mechanical
restraint shall cease immediately once risk of harm has passed.
(c)
"Mechanical
restraint" does not include:
(i)
A seatbelt of a type found in an ordinary passenger
vehicle or an age-appropriate child safety seat;
(ii)
A
medically-necessary device (such as a wheelchair seatbelt or a gait belt) used
for supporting or positioning an individual's body; or
(iii)
A device that
is routinely used during a medical procedure for patients without developmental
disabilities.
(13)
"Precisely-defined pattern of behavior" means a documented and predictable
sequence of actions that if left uninterrupted, will very likely result in
physical harm to self or others.
(14)
"Prohibited
measure" means a method that shall not be used by persons or entities providing
specialized services. "Prohibited measures" include:
(a)
Prone
restraint.
(b)
Use of a manual restraint or mechanical restraint that
has the potential to inhibit or restrict an individual's ability to breathe or
that is medically contraindicated.
(c)
Use of a manual
restraint or mechanical restraint that causes pain or harm to an
individual.
(d)
Disabling an individual's communication
device.
(e)
Denial of breakfast, lunch, dinner, snacks, or
beverages (excluding denial of snacks or beverages for an individual with
primary polydipsia or a compulsive eating disorder attributed to a diagnosed
condition such as "Prader-Willi Syndrome," and denial is based on specific
medical treatment of the diagnosed condition and approved by the human rights
committee).
(f)
Placing an individual in a room with no
light.
(g)
Subjecting an individual to damaging or painful
sound.
(h)
Application of electric shock to an individual's body
(excluding electroconvulsive therapy prescribed by a physician as a clinical
intervention to treat a diagnosed medical condition and administered by a
physician or a credentialed advanced practice registered
nurse).
(i)
Subjecting an individual to any humiliating or
derogatory treatment.
(j)
Squirting an individual with any substance as an
inducement or consequence for behavior.
(k)
Using any
restrictive measure for punishment, retaliation, convenience of providers, or
as a substitute for specialized services.
(15)
"Prone
restraint" means a method of intervention where an individual's face and/ or
frontal part of an individual's body is placed in a downward position touching
any surface for any amount of time.
(16)
"Provider" means
any person or entity that provides specialized services.
(17)
"Qualified
intellectual disability professional" has the same meaning as in
42 C.F.R.
483.430 as in effect on the effective date of
this rule.
(18)
"Restrictive measure" means a method of last resort
that may be used by persons or entities providing specialized services only
when necessary to keep people safe and with prior approval in accordance with
paragraph (H) of this rule. "Restrictive measures" include:
(a)
Chemical
restraint;
(b)
Manual restraint;
(c)
Mechanical
restraint;
(d)
Rights restriction; and
(e)
Time-out
(19)
"Rights
restriction" means restriction of an individual's rights as enumerated in
section 5123.62 of the Revised
Code.
(a)
A
behavioral support strategy may include a rights restriction only when an
individual's actions pose risk of harm or are very likely to result in the
individual being the subject of a legal sanction such as eviction, arrest, or
incarceration.
(b)
Absent risk of harm or likelihood of legal sanction, an
individual's rights shall not be restricted (e.g., by imposition of arbitrary
schedules or limitation on consumption of tobacco
products).
(20)
"Risk of harm" means there exists a direct and serious
risk of physical harm to an individual or another person. For risk of
harm:
(a)
An
individual must be capable of causing physical harm to self or others;
and
(b)
The individual must be causing physical harm to self or
others or very likely to begin doing so.
(21)
"Service and
support administrator" means a person, regardless of title, employed by or
under contract with a county board to perform the functions of service and
support administration and who holds the appropriate certification in
accordance with rule
5123:2-5-02 of the
Administrative Code.
(22)
"Specialized services" means any program or service
designed and operated to serve primarily individuals with developmental
disabilities, including a program or service provided by an entity licensed or
certified by the department. If there is a question as to whether a provider or
entity under contract with a provider is providing specialized services, the
provider or contract entity may request that the director make a determination.
The director's determination is not subject to appeal.
(23)
"Team," as
applicable, has the same meaning as in rule
5123-4-02 of the Administrative
Code or means an "interdisciplinary team" as that term is used in
42 C.F.R.
483.440 as in effect on the effective date of
this rule.
(24)
"Time-out" means confining an individual in a room or
area and preventing the individual from leaving the room or area by applying
physical force or by closing a door or constructing another barrier, including
placement in such a room or area when a staff person remains in the room or
area.
(a)
A
behavioral support strategy may include time-out only when an individual's
actions pose risk of harm.
(b)
Time-out shall
not exceed thirty minutes for any one incident nor one hour in any twenty-four
hour period.
(c)
A time-out room or area shall not be key-locked, but
the door may be held shut by a staff person or by a mechanism that requires
constant physical pressure from a staff person to keep the mechanism
engaged.
(d)
A time-out room or area shall be adequately lighted and
ventilated and provide a safe environment for the individual.
(e)
An individual in
a time-out room or area shall be protected from hazardous conditions including
but not limited to, sharp corners and objects, uncovered light fixtures, or
unprotected electrical outlets.
(f)
An individual in
a time-out room or area shall be under constant visual supervision by
staff.
(g)
Time-out shall cease immediately once risk of harm has
passed or if the individual engages in self-abuse, becomes incontinent, or
shows other signs of illness.
(h)
"Time-out" does
not include periods when an individual, for a limited and specified time, is
separated from others in an unlocked room or area for the purpose of
self-regulation of behavior and is not physically restrained or prevented from
leaving the room or area by physical barriers.
(D)
Development of a behavioral support strategy
(1)
The focus of a
behavioral support strategy is the proactive creation of supportive
environments that enhance an individual's quality of life by understanding and
respecting the individual's needs and expanding opportunities for the
individual to communicate and exercise choice and control through
identification and implementation of positive measures such as:
(a)
Emphasizing
alternative ways for the individual to communicate needs and to have needs
met;
(b)
Adjusting the physical or social
environment;
(c)
Addressing sensory stimuli;
(d)
Adjusting
schedules; and
(e)
Establishing trusting relationships.
(2)
A
behavioral support strategy that includes restrictive measures requires:
(a)
Documentation
that demonstrates that positive measures have been employed and have been
determined ineffective.
(b)
An assessment conducted within the past twelve months
that clearly describes:
(i)
The behavior that poses risk of harm or likelihood of
legal sanction or the individual's engagement in a precisely-defined pattern of
behavior that is very likely to result in risk of harm;
(ii)
The level of
harm or type of legal sanction that could reasonably be expected to occur with
the behavior;
(iii)
When the behavior is likely to occur;
(iv)
The individual's
interpersonal, environmental, medical, mental health, communication, sensory,
and emotional needs; diagnosis; and life history including traumatic
experiences as a means to gain insight into origins and patterns of the
individual's actions; and
(v)
The nature and degree of risk to the individual if the
restrictive measure is implemented.
(c)
A description of
actions to be taken to:
(i)
Mitigate risk of harm or likelihood of legal
sanction;
(ii)
Reduce and ultimately eliminate the need for
restrictive measures; and
(iii)
Ensure
environments where the individual has access to preferred activities and is
less likely to engage in unsafe actions due to boredom, frustration, lack of
effective communication, or unrecognized health problems.
(3)
A behavioral support strategy shall never include
prohibited measures.
(4)
Persons who conduct assessments and develop behavioral
support strategies that include restrictive measures shall:
(a)
Hold a valid
license issued by the Ohio board of psychology;
(b)
Hold a valid
license issued by the Ohio counselor, social worker and marriage and family
therapist board;
(c)
Hold a valid physician license issued by the state
medical board of Ohio; or
(d)
Hold a bachelor's or graduate-level degree from an
accredited college or university and have at least three years of paid,
full-time (or equivalent part-time) experience in developing and/or
implementing behavioral support and/or risk reduction strategies or
plans.
(5)
A behavioral support strategy that includes restrictive
measures shall:
(a)
Be designed in a manner that promotes healing,
recovery, and resilience;
(b)
Have the goal of helping the individual to achieve
outcomes and pursue interests while reducing or eliminating the need for
restrictive measures to ensure safety;
(c)
Describe tangible
outcomes and goals and how progress toward achievement of outcomes and goals
will be identified;
(d)
Recognize the role environment has on
behavior;
(e)
Capitalize on the individual's strengths to meet
challenges and needs;
(f)
Delineate restrictive measures to be implemented and
identify those who are responsible for implementation;
(g)
Specify steps to
be taken to ensure the safety of the individual and others;
(h)
As applicable,
identify needed services and supports to assist the individual in meeting
court-ordered community controls such as mandated sex offender registration,
drug-testing, or participation in mental health treatment; and
(i)
As applicable,
outline necessary coordination with other entities (e.g., courts, prisons,
hospitals, and law enforcement) charged with the individual's care,
confinement, or reentry to the community.
(6)
A behavioral
support strategy that includes chemical restraint, manual restraint, or
time-out will specify when and how the provider will notify the individual's
guardian when such restraint is used.
(7)
When a behavioral
support strategy that includes restrictive measures is proposed by an
individual and the individual's team, the qualified intellectual disability
professional or the service and support administrator, as applicable,
shall:
(a)
Ensure the strategy is developed in accordance with the principles of
person-centered planning and trauma-informed care and incorporated as an
integral part of the individual service plan.
(b)
When indicated,
seek input from persons with specialized expertise to address an individual's
specific support needs.
(c)
Secure informed consent of the individual or the
individual's guardian, as applicable.
(d)
Submit to the
human rights committee the strategy and documentation, including the record of
restrictive measures described in paragraph (F)(4) of this rule, based upon an
assessment that clearly indicates:
(i)
The justification for the proposed restrictive measure,
that is:
(a)
When manual restraint, mechanical restraint, or time-out is
proposed -- risk of harm;
(b)
When chemical restraint is proposed -- risk of harm or
how the individual's engagement in a precisely-defined pattern of behavior is
very likely to result in risk of harm; or
(c)
When rights
restriction is proposed -- risk of harm or how the individual's actions are
very likely to result in the individual being the subject of a legal
sanction.
(ii)
The nature and degree of risk to the individual if the
restrictive measure is implemented.
(e)
Ensure the
strategy is reviewed and approved in accordance with paragraph (H) of this rule
prior to implementation and whenever the behavioral support strategy is revised
to add restrictive measures.
(f)
Ensure the
strategy is reviewed by the individual and the individual's team at least every
ninety calendar days or more frequently when specified by the human rights
committee to determine and document the effectiveness of the strategy and
whether the strategy should be continued, discontinued, or revised.
(i)
The review shall
consider:
(a)
Numeric data on changes in the severity or frequency of
behaviors that had been targeted for reduction due to a threat to safety or
wellbeing;
(b)
New skills that have been developed which have reduced
or eliminated threats to safety or wellbeing;
(c)
The individual's
self-report of overall satisfaction in achieving desired outcomes and pursuing
interests; and
(d)
Observations by paid staff and/or natural supports as
they relate to safety or wellbeing and the individual's achievement of desired
outcomes and pursuit of interests.
(ii)
When a manual
restraint has been used in the past ninety calendar days, the review shall
include seeking the perspective of the individual and at least one direct
support professional involved in use of the manual restraint regarding the
reason the manual restraint occurred and what could be done differently in the
future to avoid manual restraint.
(iii)
A decision to
continue the strategy shall be based upon review of up-to-date information
justifying the continuation of the strategy.
(F)
Implementation of behavioral support strategies with
restrictive measures
(1)
Restrictive measures shall be implemented with
sufficient safeguards and supervision to ensure the health, welfare, and rights
of individuals receiving specialized services.
(2)
Each person
providing specialized services to an individual with a behavioral support
strategy that includes restrictive measures shall successfully complete
training in the strategy prior to serving the individual.
(3)
After each
incidence of manual restraint, a provider shall take any measures necessary to
ensure the safety and wellbeing of the individual who was restrained,
individuals who witnessed the manual restraint, and staff and minimize traumas
for all involved.
(4)
Each provider shall maintain a record of the date,
time, and antecedent factors regarding each event of a restrictive measure
other than a restrictive measure that is not based on antecedent factors (e.g.,
bed alarm or locked cabinet). The record for each event of a manual restraint
or a mechanical restraint will include the duration. The provider will share
the record with the individual or the individual's guardian, as applicable, and
the individual's team whenever the individual's behavioral support strategy is
being reviewed or reconsidered.
(G)
Establishment of
human rights committees
(1)
Each county board and each intermediate care facility
for individuals with intellectual disabilities shall actively participate in an
established human rights committee. A human rights committee may be established
by a county board or an intermediate care facility for individuals with
intellectual disabilities acting independently or jointly in collaboration with
one or more other county boards and/or intermediate care facilities for
individuals with intellectual disabilities. The human rights committee
shall:
(a)
Be
comprised of at least four persons;
(b)
Include at least
one individual who receives or is eligible to receive specialized
services;
(c)
Include qualified persons who have either experience or
training in contemporary practices for behavioral support; and
(d)
Reflect a balance
of representatives from each of the following two groups:
(i)
Individuals who
receive or are eligible to receive specialized services or family members or
guardians of individuals who receive or are eligible to receive specialized
services; and
(ii)
County boards, intermediate care facilities for
individuals with intellectual disabilities or other providers, or other
professionals.
(2)
All information
and documents provided to the human rights committee and all discussions of the
committee are confidential and shall not be shared or discussed with anyone
other than the individual, the individual's guardian, and the individual's
team.
(3)
Members of the human rights committee shall receive
department-approved training within three months of appointment to the
committee in:
(a)
Rights of individuals as enumerated in section
5123.62 of the Revised
Code;
(b)
Person-centered planning;
(c)
Informed
consent;
(d)
Confidentiality; and
(e)
The requirements
of this rule.
(4)
Members of the human rights committee shall annually
receive department-approved training in relevant topics which may include but
are not limited to:
(a)
Self-advocacy and self-determination;
(b)
Role of guardians
and section 5126.043 of the Revised
Code;
(c)
Effect of traumatic experiences on behavior;
and
(d)
Court-ordered community controls and the role of the
court, the county board or intermediate care facility for individuals with
intellectual disabilities, and the human rights
committee.
(H)
Review of
behavioral support strategies that include restrictive measures
There are two distinct processes for
review of behavioral support strategies that include restrictive measures based
on the nature of the request:
(1)
Emergency
request.
(a)
An
emergency request for a behavioral support strategy that includes restrictive
measures shall consist of:
(i)
A description of the restrictive measures to be
implemented;
(ii)
Documentation of risk of harm or legal sanction which
demonstrates the situation is an emergency;
(iii)
A description
of positive measures that have been implemented and proved ineffective or
infeasible;
(iv)
Any medical contraindications; and
(v)
Informed consent
by the individual or the individual's guardian, as applicable.
(b)
Prior
to implementation of a behavioral support strategy submitted via the emergency
request process, the strategy must be approved by:
(i)
A quorum of
members of the human rights committee in accordance with
42 C.F.R.
483.440 as in effect on the effective date of
this rule for an individual who resides in an intermediate care facility for
individuals with intellectual disabilities; or
(ii)
The
superintendent of the county board or the superintendent's designee for an
individual who does not reside in an intermediate care facility for individuals
with intellectual disabilities.
(c)
A behavioral
support strategy approved via the emergency request process may be in place for
a period not to exceed forty-five calendar days. Continuation of the strategy
beyond the initial forty-five calendar days requires approval by the human
rights committee in accordance with the process for a routine request described
in paragraph (H)(2) of this rule.
(2)
Routine
request.
(a)
Absent an emergency, a human rights committee shall review a
request to implement a behavioral support strategy that includes restrictive
measures.
(b)
An individual or the individual's guardian, as
applicable, is to be notified at least seventy-two hours in advance of the
date, time, and location of the human rights committee meeting at which the
individual's behavioral support strategy will be reviewed. The individual or
guardian has the right to attend to present related information in advance of
the human rights committee commencing its review.
(c)
In its review of
an individual's behavioral support strategy, the human rights committee is
to:
(i)
Ensure
that the planning process outlined in this rule has been followed and that the
individual or the individual's guardian, as applicable, has provided informed
consent.
(ii)
Ensure that the proposed restrictive measures are
necessary to reduce risk of harm or likelihood of legal
sanction.
(iii)
When indicated, seek input from persons with
specialized expertise to address an individual's specific support
needs.
(iv)
Ensure that the overall outcome of the behavioral
support strategy promotes the physical, emotional, and psychological wellbeing
of the individual while reducing risk of harm or likelihood of legal
sanction.
(v)
Ensure that a restrictive measure is temporary in
nature and occurs only in specifically-defined situations based on:
(a)
Risk of harm for
manual restraint, mechanical restraint, or timeout;
(b)
Risk of harm or
an individual's engagement in a precisely-defined pattern of behavior that is
very likely to result in risk of harm for chemical restraint;
or
(c)
Risk of harm or likelihood of legal sanction for a
rights restriction.
(vi)
Verify that any
behavioral support strategy that includes restrictive measures also
incorporates positive measures designed to enable the individual to feel safe,
respected, and valued while emphasizing choice, self-determination, and an
improved quality of life.
(vii)
Determine the
period of time for which a restrictive measure is appropriate and may approve a
strategy that includes restrictive measures for any number of days not to
exceed three hundred sixty-five.
(viii)
Approve in
whole or in part, reject in whole or in part, monitor, and when indicated,
reauthorize behavioral support strategies that include restrictive
measures.
(ix)
Communicate the committee's determination including an
explanation of its rejection of a strategy in writing to the qualified
intellectual disability professional or service and support administrator that
submitted the request for approval.
(d)
The qualified
intellectual disability professional or service and support administrator shall
communicate in writing to the individual or the individual's guardian, as
applicable, the determination of the human rights committee including an
explanation of rejection of a strategy as well as the individual's or
guardian's right to seek reconsideration when the human rights committee
rejects a strategy.
(e)
An individual or the individual's guardian, as
applicable, may seek reconsideration of rejection by the human rights committee
of a strategy that includes restrictive measures by submitting the request for
reconsideration with additional information provided as rationale for the
request to the qualified intellectual disability professional or service and
support administrator, as applicable, in writing within fourteen calendar days
of being informed of the rejection. The qualified intellectual disability
professional or service and support administrator is to forward the request to
the human rights committee within seventy-two hours. The human rights committee
will consider the request for reconsideration and respond in writing to the
individual or guardian within fourteen calendar days of receiving the
request.
(f)
An individual who resides in an intermediate care
facility for individuals with intellectual disabilities or the individual's
guardian, as applicable, may appeal to the facility's specially constituted
committee in accordance with the facility's procedure if the individual or
guardian, as applicable, is dissatisfied with the strategy or the process used
for development of the strategy.
(g)
An individual who
does not reside in an intermediate care facility for individuals with
intellectual disabilities or the individual's guardian, as applicable, may seek
administrative resolution in accordance with rule
5123-4-04 of the Administrative
Code if the individual or guardian is dissatisfied with the strategy or the
process used for development of the strategy.
(L)
Department
oversight
(1)
The department will take immediate action as necessary to
protect the health and welfare of individuals which may include, but is not
limited to:
(a)
Suspension of a behavioral support strategy not developed,
implemented, documented, or monitored in accordance with this rule or where
trends and patterns of data suggest the need for further
review;
(b)
Provision of technical assistance in development or
redevelopment of a behavioral support strategy; and
(c)
Referral to other
state agencies or licensing bodies, as indicated.
(2)
The department
will compile and analyze data regarding behavioral support strategies for
purposes of determining methods for enhancing risk reduction efforts and
outcomes, reducing the frequency of restrictive measures, and identifying
technical assistance and training needs. The department will make the data and
analyses available.
(3)
The department may periodically select a sample of
behavioral support strategies for review to ensure that strategies are
developed, implemented, documented, and monitored in accordance with this
rule.
(4)
The department will conduct reviews of county boards
and providers as necessary to ensure the health and welfare of individuals and
compliance with this rule.
Failure to comply with this rule may be
considered by the department in any regulatory capacity, including
certification, licensure, and accreditation.