Utah Admin. Code R907-65-13 - In-Kind Compensation

(1) The department is authorized to enter into agreements for longitudinal access to the right-of-way of the interstate system with telecommunications facility providers which offer, in lieu of or in addition to monetary compensation, in-kind compensation. In-kind compensation may include, without limitation, delivery to the department for its own uses and purposes of conduit, innerduct, dark fiber, access points, telecommunications equipment, telecommunications services, bandwidth and other telecommunications facilities. The agreement shall set forth the in-kind compensation.

(2) The department shall determine the present value of the in-kind compensation according to the methods set forth in R907-65-12. The department shall prepare an analysis setting forth its valuation at or before the time it executes the agreement. The valuation analysis need not be included in the agreement.

(3) The department shall value the in-kind compensation as follows:

(a) Facilities for Department Use Only. Electronic equipment, conduit, fiber and other telecommunications hardware and software contributed to the department shall be valued on a present value basis at the estimated, reasonable cost to the telecommunications facility provider of procuring and installing the same.

(b) Joint Trenching. The present value of the estimated, reasonable cost to the telecommunications facility provider of joint trenching for placing conduit, fiber and other facilities of both the provider (and its customers) and the department shall be proportionately allocated to the department as a component of the present value of the in-kind compensation. The proportion allocated to the department shall equal the total estimated, reasonable cost of the trenching work multiplied by a fraction. The numerator of the fraction shall equal the amount of conduit and innerduct space to be contributed to the department under the agreement. The denominator of the fraction shall equal the total amount of conduit space the telecommunications facility provider is authorized to install under the agreement. Single duct conduit space shall be measured using the planned diameter of the conduit. Multi-duct conduit space shall be measured by summing the planned diameters of each innerduct in the conduit.

(c) Other Jointly Used Facilities. The present value of the estimated, reasonable cost to the telecommunications facility provider of providing any other telecommunications facility which is shared jointly by the provider and the department shall be proportionately allocated to the department as a component of the present value of the in-kind compensation. The department shall determine the proportion to be allocated to the department based on the percentage of use or benefit to which each party will be entitled under the agreement.

(d) Warranties; Maintenance and Operating Covenants. The department shall determine the present value of equipment warranties, warranties of conduit, fiber or other components, software warranties, maintenance covenants and operating covenants based on the reasonable, estimated cost of purchasing such warranties, maintenance and operating contracts from manufacturers or other third parties (if not already included in the cost to purchase the equipment, conduit, fiber, other components or software).

(e) Summation of In-Kind Values. The total present value of the in-kind compensation shall be the sum of the present values determined under subsections (a) through (d) above.

(4) The department shall require annual or lump sum monetary compensation (determined according to the methods set forth in R907-65-12 ), in addition to the in-kind compensation, if the present value of the in-kind compensation is less than the present value of the annual monetary compensation the department would require over the term of the agreement under R907-65-8, R907-65-9, R907-65-10 and R907-65-11. The amount of the annual or lump sum monetary compensation shall be the difference in such present values.

(5) The department may accept in-kind compensation with a present value in excess of the present value of annual monetary compensation payments which would be required under R907-65-8, R907-65-9, R907-65-10 and R907-65-11 if the telecommunications facility provider consents in writing and gives a written waiver and release of all claims and protections arising under federal or Utah law by reason of such excess value. The waiver and release shall be in form approved by the director.

(6) Before entering into an in-kind compensation agreement, the department shall obtain from the telecommunications facility provider its valuations of the in-kind compensation. The telecommunications facility provider may provide the department information on its costs in order to assist the department in determining in-kind compensation value. The department shall reasonably consider such valuation and cost information in making its determination, but is not bound by the valuation or cost information submitted.

Notes

Utah Admin. Code R907-65-13