Utah Admin. Code R305-7-309 - Agency Record

(1) The final agency record shall consist of an Initial Record and an Adjudicative Record.

(2)

(a) The Initial Record shall be prepared by the Director and shall consist of background documents for the matter that shall be deemed to be authenticated for purposes of the hearing and motions, and may be introduced as evidence by any party. The Initial Record is not intended to take the place of discovery or of the proffer by parties of documentary evidence.

(b) The Initial Record shall be indexed and compiled in chronological order. Each page of the Initial Record shall be numbered for ease of reference. A paper and an electronic copy of the Initial Record shall be filed with the ALJ. An electronic copy of the Initial Record shall be filed and served as provided in R305-7-104(3). Electronic records shall meet the requirements for electronic filing and service in R305-7-104(3).

(3) The Initial Record document index shall include, to the extent they exist and are relevant to the issues raised in the Request for Agency Action, any documentation designated by the Director as part of the basis for issuing the Notice of Violation or Initial Order.

(4) Documents other than those specified in R305-7-309(3) may be included in the Initial Record only upon the agreement of the parties. Documents that the parties cannot agree upon may be submitted in the course of the proceeding. Failure of a party to object to inclusion of a document in the Initial Record shall be deemed to be agreement to its inclusion in the initial record and to its authenticity.

(5) If many of the documents or large parts of the documents that would ordinarily constitute the Initial Record are irrelevant to the issues raised in the proceeding, the Director may propose a more limited Initial Record. If a matter involves a multi-volume document, for example, the Director may propose to exclude the parts of the permit that are unrelated, e.g., emergency response requirements if the dispute is about waste sampling.

(6) Results of analytical analyses of samples documented in the Initial Record are deemed to be accurate unless specifically objected to no later than 15 days before the date the Director's preliminary witness lists are due.

(7) Procedure for preparing the Initial Record.

(a) Unless the ALJ directs otherwise, the Director shall compile a draft index of documents in the Initial Record, provide the draft index to the other parties. The Director shall allow time for the other parties to comment on the draft index.

(b) After consideration of the comments, the Director shall prepare the Initial Record by compiling it in chronological order, numbering each page and preparing an index. The Director shall:

(i) file and serve an electronic copy of the record in accordance with the requirements of R305-7-104(3); or

(ii) make a paper copy of the record available for review during normal working hours, and file and serve a copy of the record's index as provided in R305-7-104.

(8) Any challenges to the Initial Record shall be made by motion within 10 business days of the date the record or index is served under paragraph (7)(b).

(9) The Adjudicatory Record consists of all documents filed or issued in the proceeding beginning with the Request for Agency Action.

Notes

Utah Admin. Code R305-7-309