Utah Admin. Code R655-14-20 - Procedures and Standards for Orders Resulting from Service of an Initial Order

(1) Consent Order:

(a) If the respondent substantially agrees with or does not contest the statements of fact in the IO, or if the parties agree to specific amendments to the statements of fact in the IO, the parties may enter into a Consent Order by stipulating to the facts and either or both of the following:

(i) Negotiated administrative penalties;

(ii) Negotiated replacement of water; or

(iii) Negotiated reimbursement of enforcement costs.

(b) A Consent Order based on that stipulation, shall be prepared by the Enforcement Engineer for execution by the parties. The executed Consent Order shall be reviewed by the Presiding Officer and, if found to be acceptable, will be signed and issued by the Presiding Officer.

(c) A Consent Order issued by the Presiding Officer is not subject to reconsideration or judicial review.

(2) Final Judgment and Order Without Hearing: If the respondent does not request a hearing or is not granted a request for a hearing, participates by attending a preliminary conference or otherwise presents relevant information to the Presiding Officer, but is unable or unwilling to negotiate a stipulated Consent Order, the Presiding Officer shall issue a Final Judgment and Order based on the record, as defined in this rule.

(3) Final Judgment and Order After Hearing: If the respondent timely and properly requests a hearing, the hearing request is granted, the respondent participates by attending all scheduled preliminary conferences, and/or by attending the hearing, but is unwilling or unable to negotiate a stipulated Consent Order, the Presiding Officer shall issue a Final Judgment and Order based upon the record, as defined in this rule.

(4) Default Order: The Presiding Officer may issue a Default Order if the respondent fails to participate as follows:

(a) The respondent does not timely request a hearing and fails to respond to the IO; or

(b) After proper notice the respondent fails to attend a preliminary conference scheduled by the Presiding Officer; or

(c) After proper notice, the respondent fails to attend a hearing scheduled by the Presiding Officer.

(5) A respondent who fails to participate pursuant to an IO waives any right to request reconsideration of the Final Judgment and Order per Section R655-14-25, but may petition for judicial review per Section R655-14-29.

Notes

Utah Admin. Code R655-14-20